There is a moment in Scripture that has raised questions for centuries, one that has challenged theological assumptions, sparked debate among believers, divided scholars, and even prompted criticism of long-held Christian practices.
It is the account of the thief on the cross.
This man publicly acknowledged Jesus as the Christ while hanging beside Him in his final moments. He had been justly sentenced to death for a life of sin (Luke 23:41). He had no record of good works, no known religious background, and no opportunity for water baptism. Scripture does not even describe an outward or visible spiritual experience taking place in that moment. And yet, Jesus declared to him: “Truly, I say to you, today you will be with Me in Paradise.” (Luke 23:43)
To some believers, this poses curiosity and raises questions. To others, it has remained a sticking point that they just can't seem to grasp, wondering, was this account contradictory to the rest of Scripture?
I have always found the answers to be both simple and consistent with the whole message of Christ. However, it has become clear that many believers struggle with this passage, which has placed a burden on my heart. This article is written in hopes of addressing misunderstandings and clarifying what this moment truly teaches us about salvation, grace, and the character of God.
-----------------------------------------------------
At its core, this scene teaches a powerful truth: God is willing to meet us precisely where we are. He meets us in brokenness. He meets us in regret. He meets us in desperation and in chaos, in failure, and even in our final moments.
Scripture consistently affirms this reality. “The Lord is near to the brokenhearted and saves the crushed in spirit” (Psalm 34:18). In his final moments, the thief had nothing to offer, only repentance, humility, and faith. To Jesus, that was enough.
The moment and the environment in which someone truly encounters God varies greatly from person to person. This is not a flaw in the gospel; it is a reflection of God’s grace. The thief’s salvation stands as undeniable proof that salvation is initiated by God and received through faith, not earned through opportunity, ritual, or longevity.
Throughout history, many people have come to faith in Christ on their deathbeds. They believed that Jesus is the Son of God, that He died and rose again for the forgiveness of sins, and they surrendered their lives to Him in their final moments. Are these professions invalid because they lacked time for good works or baptism? Scripture gives a clear answer: no. How is this any different from the thief?
Salvation has always been by grace through faith: “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast.” (Ephesians 2:8–9)
Like the thief on the cross, these individuals responded to the call of Christ when the calling and the opportunity arose. Circumstance and timing prevented further obedience, but God still met them where they were.
Notably, Jesus wasn't verbally preaching, teaching, or calling out to the crowd for repentance. The thief bore witness to Christ's posture. His own faith, kindness, and humility. It was His witness alone that convinced the man hanging next to Him that He was not dying without purpose.
Now, let's consider a more typical scenario.
On the other hand, many people encounter God earlier in life, through the church, through nature, through the witness of family and friends... Their circumstances are different, and with that difference comes responsibility. Let me reiterate that point- faith with time and opportunity comes with responsibility.
Jesus taught that greater knowledge brings greater accountability: “Everyone to whom much was given, of him much will be required” (Luke 12:48). When God grants time, health, and opportunity, He invites believers into a life of obedience, faith expressed through baptism, service, and good works (Matthew 28:19–20; James 2:17). This difference in timing does not change the reward; it changes the stewardship.
Jesus addressed this exact tension in the parable of the laborers in the vineyard (Matthew 20:1–16). Some workers labored all day, while others worked only the final hour, yet all received the same wage. When the early workers complained, the landowner replied: “Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me? Or do you begrudge my generosity?” (Matthew 20:15)
The lesson is clear: eternal life is not earned by duration but granted by grace. Whether someone follows Christ for a lifetime or turns to Him in their final breath, the gift remains the same, eternity with God.
Scripture also reminds us that no one comes to God on their own initiative, which can not be predicted by mankind: “No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him.” (John 6:44)
God is not lost- we are. Therefore, we cannot determine when or how someone will be drawn to Him, nor can we judge the timing or circumstances of their response. Our role is not to evaluate another person’s calling but to trust the wisdom of the One who calls.
The central truth in all of this is simple: God requires faith and acceptance above all else. Faith has power. Faith heals. Faith saves. Faith sets people free (Hebrews 11:6; Romans 10:9–10). What follows- obedience, baptism, works- flows from faith, not the other way around.
Some believers serve God for decades. Others for moments. Yet God remains generous to all who call upon His name (Romans 10:13).
In summary, we must resist the temptation to place God inside human limitations or theological boxes. He alone possesses all authority, wisdom, and understanding. Our response should not be suspicion, but gratitude.
Gratitude that He calls. Gratitude that He saves. Gratitude that He meets us where we are.
Those who have learned to die to themselves will recognize the truth in this message. Those who are struggling may still have questions… and that is okay. If this is you, I encourage you to take those questions to God in prayer. You really were made for more!
~ Devin
Devin Osborne
